Is Student Loan Forgiveness Worth It? – Pros & Cons

Student loan forgiveness is an issue that has generated significant discussion in recent years. It can be a viable solution for borrowers who are struggling to make payments, but there are also potential drawbacks which should not be overlooked. This article will explore the pros and cons of student loan forgiveness programs, examining how they could affect borrowers as well as their credit score and future financial prospects.

The first section of this article will analyze the benefits associated with student loan forgiveness, such as reducing or eliminating debt obligations and having more money available each month. Additionally, it will look at how these types of programs can provide relief from repayment stress and open up opportunities for further education or career advancement.

Finally, the second section of this article will consider some possible negative effects of student loan forgiveness programs. These include tax implications, reduced access to certain types of loans in the future, and even increased interest rates on other forms of borrowing due to lowered credit scores. Overall, it is important to assess all aspects before making a decision about whether or not participating in student loan forgiveness is right for you.



Student loan forgiveness is a form of financial aid, typically provided by the government or other organizations, in which all or part of an individual’s student loans are forgiven. It can be granted to individuals who demonstrate need, based on criteria such as income level and family size. The amount of loan forgiveness varies depending on the institution providing it and the specific circumstances of each borrower.

The primary objective of student loan forgiveness programs is to reduce student debt burden for those with low incomes and limited access to traditional forms of credit. By reducing overall student debt levels, these programs aim to make higher education more accessible and affordable for people from lower-income backgrounds. Additionally, they may provide incentives for students to pursue careers in public service that require specialized training but offer relatively low pay compared with private sector jobs.


Qualifications For Loan Forgiveness

Student loan forgiveness programs may be beneficial to some borrowers, depending on their qualifications. The requirements for loan forgiveness can vary greatly, with certain types of loans eligible for different levels of debt relief.

For instance, the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program is available to those who work in specific public service roles such as government or nonprofit organizations and make 120 qualifying monthly payments on their federal student loans over a 10-year period. Additionally, income-driven repayment plans are available for low-income borrowers that allow them to pay a set percentage of their discretionary income each month toward their loans; after making consecutive payments for 20 years, any remaining balance could possibly be forgiven.

Borrowers should research the various options available to determine if they meet the necessary qualifications before deciding whether pursuing student loan forgiveness is right for them.


Benefits Of Student Loan Forgiveness

Student loan forgiveness can provide multiple benefits to borrowers. Forgiveness of student loans may enable debt-burdened individuals to obtain financial freedom and make other investments in their lives. In addition, it can also reduce the amount of money that must be paid each month towards student loan repayment, allowing for more disposable income.

The ability to have one’s student loans forgiven is an attractive option for those who are experiencing severe difficulty meeting their payments or do not anticipate being able to pay off their debt within a reasonable amount of time. Additionally, some people find themselves unable to pursue certain career paths due to the large amounts of debt they will incur over the course of their education. Student loan forgiveness may provide these individuals with a viable solution which could otherwise be unattainable without taking on significant additional debt.


Drawbacks Of Student Loan Forgiveness

Student loan forgiveness may not be the best option for everyone. One of the main drawbacks is its cost. Depending on the program, borrowers can find themselves paying large sums in taxes as a result of their forgiven debt. This could potentially leave them worse off than before they applied for student loan forgiveness. Additionally, it takes several years to qualify for most programs and even then there is no guarantee that all loans will be forgiven.

Furthermore, if a borrower does have part or all of their loans forgiven, this may affect eligibility for certain government benefits such as Social Security payments. The amount paid out by these programs could be reduced depending on how much of a person’s debt was forgiven. Therefore, individuals should take into account any potential downside when considering whether student loan forgiveness is worth it or not.


Alternatives To Loan Forgiveness

For those who cannot take advantage of student loan forgiveness, there are alternatives that may help ease the burden. These include income-driven repayment plans, consolidation loans and refinancing loans.

  • Income-Driven Repayment Plans: This option adjusts a borrower’s monthly payments to an affordable level based on their total income. Qualifying borrowers may also be eligible for Loan Forgiveness after 20 or 25 years of making qualifying payments under this plan.
  • Consolidation Loans: This allows multiple federal student loans to be combined into one large loan with a single payment each month. Interest rates can vary depending on the current market rate and borrowing history, so it is important to compare offers from different lenders before deciding which consolidation loan works best for you.
  • Refinancing Loans: By refinancing your existing student loans, you can lower the interest rate and combine all of your debts into one simple payment every month. It is worth noting that private lenders often have more strict requirements for qualification than federal lenders do when considering applicants for refinance loans; however these types of loans could offer significant savings in the long run if approved by a lender.

It is important to understand all options available as well as potential risks associated with them prior to entering any type of loan agreement with either government or private entities. Additionally, speaking with a financial advisor and doing research online can give valuable insight into what choices are most beneficial financially over the long-term period of time.


Impact On Credit Score

The impact of student loan forgiveness on one’s credit score is an important consideration for many borrowers. If a borrower has their loans forgiven, it will generally appear as “paid in full” or “settled” on the credit report which could be seen positively by lenders and creditors. This can help to improve a person’s credit score if they have had trouble making payments in the past. On the other hand, if the loan was settled for less than what was owed, this could negatively affect a borrower’s credit score and make obtaining future lines of credit more difficult.

Additionally, having the debt discharged through bankruptcy may also hurt one’s credit score significantly. Ultimately, it is essential that those considering student loan forgiveness understand how it might affect their credit before deciding whether or not to pursue such an option.



This article explored the pros and cons of student loan forgiveness, as well as the qualifications for receiving it. The benefits include not having to repay large sums of money, payments being removed from monthly budget plans, and a reduction in stress levels. However, there are drawbacks such as taxes that must be paid on forgiven amounts, limited eligibility requirements, and potential job loss since some employers take into account whether an individual has had their loans discharged or partially cancelled. Alternatives to loan forgiveness were also discussed including loan consolidation, refinancing options, income-driven repayment plans, and forbearance periods. Finally, it was noted that credit scores may potentially be impacted by opting for loan forgiveness.

When considering student loan forgiveness one should weigh up all the advantages and disadvantages before making a decision. It is important to understand the implications which could arise from this choice along with ways to avoid them if possible – such as researching alternative methods like those mentioned above. Furthermore, individuals should look at their financial situation holistically before deciding on any particular course of action. Ultimately choosing student loan forgiveness requires careful thought and consideration so that an informed decision can be made about what best suits each person’s unique needs.

Scroll to Top